14 December 2007

What would you like to know about Silat Melayu?

What would you like to know about Silat Melayu that my blog does not cover yet?

Just write your questions in the comments form or email me at webmaster[at]silatmelayu.com

10 comments:

mAdMiKe said...

nadzrin,
kerisnagasostro kat MCM ader tanye psl pukulan jarak jauh dlm silat. Harap2 bole laa diexplen sambil mengaitkn isu al maunah duluh2 & cabaran uncle seekers. tq.

mAdMiKe said...

request dr aku sendiri:
What makes Silat, Silat??

1)Aku mengusulkn topic nih coz ader sestgh pihak yg x mau akui silat cekak as silat. Alasan xde bunge, xde tari, dll...
2) kalo kte tgk terdpt jugak silat yg berasaskn beladiri lain pd asalnye e.g lian padukan. So, kalaulah wujud sorg insan yg belaja beladiri laen(asing) e.g savate, graeco, pehlawani,TKD, sambo, etc..apekah yg melayakkn beliau claim beliau mengajar silat lpas menggarap beladiri2 tersebut sendiri? (dlm SB duluh2 aku igt ader 1 silat yg asalnye dr habsyah, baju merah kuning, main pedang) camne lak kalo beliau mmg dh layak aja silat (i.e tamat/ditauliah/dpt amanah/diberi kebenaran/dll) tp turut memasukkn unsur2 beladiri lain yg dia pelajari (hmm..besenye kalo blah2 utara tuh tomoi terkadang masuk)? Sejauh manekah Silat itu, Silat??
3) Based on 2, bagaimane mau differentiate seni yg digarapkn itu sebagai silat, JKD, or MMA??
Harap x keberatan membwut article. ;-)

ps: aku tlintas gak mau berforum MCM psl nih, but dr reaction2 yg lpas, ader yg mlenting..kurang indah nampaknye forum tersebut...Kalo bole dpt pendapat oldtimer2 skelian, & publish dlm SB, lg reliable utk di-cite in case pisang berbuah lemon mempelam.

GLOBAL ABJAD BLOG said...

Salam Nadzrin

As far as your blog contents are concerned, I think, it's already quite resourceful.

Thanks and regards. wassalaam

GLOBAL ABJAD BLOG said...

Salam mike.

Maafkan saya jika mencelah dalam soalan-soalan tuan. Rasanya mike boleh gunakan topik-topik yang lebih sesuai dalam blog saudara Nadzrin - contohnya 'bahagian 'controversy' dsb.

Maafkan saya sekali lagi kerana ruangan ini mungkin saudara Nadzrin khususkan komen bagi meningkatkan lagi kualiti isi kandungan blognya secara berterusan.

Namun, terserahlah kepada saudara Nadzrin untuk memutuskan samada apa yang saya cadangkan ini betul kerana blog ini adalah blognya.

Wassalaam dan diakhiri sekali lagi dengan salam kemaafan dari saya.

mAdMiKe said...

slm global (yoink, sori tatau name),

sorry if tsalah anta..but since he wrote:
"What would you like to know about Silat Melayu that my blog does not cover yet?"
well, those r the topics/subjects/questions that i would love to know, but weren't covered by this blog. + he suggested that we can either send an email or leave em here. ;-)
harap x keberatan yeh..wink2

Mohd Nadzrin Wahab said...

Assalamualaikum guys,

Hmmm... interesting to note that not many of my other posts had comments, but this one certainly has some good responses.

Mike, thanks and noted. The pukulan jarak jauh thing... I don't have much on that, especially since I myself haven't studied it and never showed any interest to. But for you, I'll definitely start looking around. It might take some time though :)

What makes silat? Wow... that's actually an article I've been preparing for a very long time. We'll just wait and see...

Poknik, thanks a lot for the support. The blog is registered to me, but everyone is invited to contribute. Try to think of it as an alternative online version of a Silat magazine. :)

Wassalam,

GLOBAL ABJAD BLOG said...

Mike and Nadzrin

Thanks for the responses.

Mike, I think I'm looking into the questions by Nadzrin in another perspective and you could be looking in yours but both perpectives are correct.

I guess, what Mike said is also true.

Nadzrin, no problem, I love to support any blog that matches my thinking and aspiration (am I being biased?) Most definitely your blog is one of them.

Regards.

mAdMiKe said...

Kikikiki...
global abjad: Yea, different ppl intepret differently ;)

Nadzrin: ahhaa..glad to hear u actually have done some work on "what makes silat?" cool..lookin fwd to read about it.. =D

Pendekar Fatani said...

Tomoi sebenarnya adalh dari silat. Lisan guru-guru tua ada katakan yang ketika pada zaman kesultanan Melayu Melaka, di selatan Thai, tomoi merupakan asas belajar (tumbuk, tendang dll) untuk pendekar di sana, selesai belajar Tomoi, mereka akan belajar kaedah bermain senjata dan ilmu perang iaitu Silat Pattani (asas serangan senjata : Tikam, Pancung, Belah/Tetak), zaman skrg Gayung Pulut, Silat Pulut, Silat Jawi, Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia. Jadi tomoi tu sebahagian dari silat.

Nak tanya,ini website Silat Melayu, kenapa ada jugak termasuk Silat Indonesia(Pencak Silat). Silat Melayu sebenarnya nama khas untk semua silat yang berasal dari Semenanjung Tanah Melayu. Pencak Silat adalah merupakan nama khas bagi silat-silat di bawah gugusan kepulauan Indonesia.

Sumber : Pendita Silat, Tuan Haji Anuar Abd. Wahab AMN (Guru Utama Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia)

Mohd Nadzrin Wahab said...

Salam hormat Pendekar Fatani,

Sejarah yang tuan kemukakan cukup menarik, malah saya sendiri pernah mendengarinya dalam versi berlainan.

"Nak tanya,ini website Silat Melayu, kenapa ada jugak termasuk Silat Indonesia(Pencak Silat)."

"Silat Melayu sebenarnya nama khas untk semua silat yang berasal dari Semenanjung Tanah Melayu."

Tambahan, yang dinamakan Melayu bukan hanya di Tanah Melayu, tetapi Sumatera juga.

"Pencak Silat adalah merupakan nama khas bagi silat-silat di bawah gugusan kepulauan Indonesia."

Malaysia dan Indonesia adalah konsep kenegaraan yang moden, padahal Kesultanan Melayu Melaka menjangkaui Sumatera dan Sulawesi sekaligus.

"Di Malaysia itu Melayu, di Indonesia itu juga Melayu" (sumber: O'ong Maryono, penulis Pencak Silat Merentang Waktu).

Salam persilatan,